Archive for the ‘Editorial’ Category

8471675

Photo: NHL.com

While people love to hate on Sidney Crosby, it’s impossible to deny that The Kid is one of the top two-way players in the league; he back checks and works hard to recover the puck in his own deffensive end, and occasionally he makes a play between the pipes as well, like he did on Nov. 3 against Anaheim.

Crosby is typically thought of as a point-scoring guy, whether he is netting the points himself or whether he is setting them up, but the reason Crosby is arguably one of the best players in the world is because of his two-way game. OK, so it will never be his trademark, like it is with a guy like Jordan Staal, but two-way play is a facet of the game that Crosby undeniably possesses.

After Evgeni Malkin’s spectacular performance in the Penguins, 6-2, victory of the Atlanta Thrashers on Tuesday night, how can there possibly be any question that Malkin deserves the Hart Memorial trophy, awarded to the league’s Most Valuable Player at the end of the season? Makin netted two goals and three assists for a five-point night against Atlanta. He just about made it a hat trick in the final minutes of the third period when he was awarded his first ever penalty shot, but the shot went wide. Regardless, Malkin proved himself in a big way in the game. (Catch the highlights here).

Crosby, Malkin and Gonchar cellebrate one of Malkins two goals.

Crosby, Malkin and Gonchar cellebrate one of Malkin's two goals (photo Yahoo! Sports).

Malkin’s closest competitor for the award (besides teammate Sidney Crosby) is fellow countryman, Alexander Ovechkin. The Capitals frontman is currently trailing Malkin in the scoring race by 12 points, but he is a valid contender for the Hart Memorial none the less. Ovechkin is an excellent hockey player who plays exciting hockey. But the thing about “Geno,” as Malkin is called in Pittsburgh, is that he continually puts his team in a position to win hockey games.

“When you look at that award, it’s an award where they look for someone specifically who puts their team over and above and makes them win and (Malkin) does that for us,” Sidney Crosby said to PittsburghPenguins.com.

I’ll simply let the numbers speak for Malkin in this case. I will just leave you with one point to consider: The majority of Malkin’s point come from assists. In fact, 70 (70!) of Malkin’s 102 points are assists. He is leading the league in assists, followed closely by teammate Crosby, who has 65 assists. In my mind, there is something noble about a player who is leading the league in points but the majority of those points came from setting up his teammates. It takes humility and true team play to tally numbers like that. On the other hand, Ovechkin leads the league in goals with 49  (90 points, third best in the league).

Evgeni Malkin

Alex Ovechkin

 

 

 

 

 

 

You Decide: Who deserves to be MVP?

Why is the NHL obsessed with St. Patricks day? The league doesn’t do this for any other holiday, but when it comes Saint Patty’s, they create an entire line of products. At the Penguins games against the Senators and Bruins this weekend, the crowd at the Mellon Arena was clad in all sorts of green garb. Many fans even had the special St. Patrick’s day green jersey’s.

94365_nav_stpats22

 

The Atlanta Thrahsers are even having a silent auction of their special St. Patricks Day jerseys (Click here for that story). Honestly, I want to know what the craze is all about? I just don’t get the NHL’s random obsession with St. Patrick’s day. Is there even one single Irish player in the NHL? Now there’s some food for thought. Well, feel free to let me know what you think about the St. Pat’s gear. Would you buy a green jersey of your favorite NHL team? Why?

On Monday, the New York Post’s beat writer for the New York Rangers, Larry Brooks, penned a column entitled “NHL Should Freeze Price Along with the Ice.” He argues that the NHL should place an across-the-board price freeze on tickets because of the looming economic recession. At first, this sounds like a nice fuzzy-wuzzy idea, for fans at least: whatever happens on Wall Street and in Detroit, you’d still only have to pay the usual $100 or so for a seat at Madison Square Garden. But examined more closely, the   economics behind the price freeze are bad news for the NHL and for fans alike. So in case Mr. Brooks missed his macroeconomics in college, here’s a little review session.

There are a few fundamentals in any market. In this case, we are concerned with the market for NHL tickets. In this market, there are a certain number of tickets available for each team to sell, this number of tickets is the quantity we are concerned with. A price freeze, in economic terms, is a “price ceiling,” because it is a concrete limit on a product’s maximum price. This is a basic supply and demand graph with a non-binding price ceiling (which you can ignore for the purpose of this economics lesson):

Market without Price Freeze, graph courtesy of Wikipedia

Market without Price Freeze, graph courtesy of Wikipedia

The place where the supply curve intersects with the demand curve is called the point of equilibrium, and it determines where the price of NHL tickets should be in relationship to the quantity—the maximum people are willing to pay for the available tickets.
Now, another basic graph that shows the effect of a “price freeze”:

Market with Price Ceiling, graph courtesy of Wikipedia

Market with Price Ceiling, graph courtesy of Wikipedia

Suppliers (NHL teams) cannot charge what they want for tickets, and some of them may be forced to drop out of the market, or at best, teams will feel a financial strain because they’re unable to charge enough for tickets to keep the team a profitable business. This would likely never be a factor for well off teams like the Rangers, but for teams in small markets and non-traditional hockey markets (Nashville, Tampa Bay, Phoenix) it might even cause clubs to fold which would lead to a reduction in the quantity of tickets in the market. A price-freeze also allows fans to buy the same tickets at a reduced price, demand will increase—of course, the cheaper the tickets, the more people want them. But there we have a disturbance in the equilibrium, as demand soars above supply which causes a shortage in tickets. I won’t get into deadweight loss—essentially the loss of economic efficiency that price ceilings cause—but I will mention that a price ceiling also increases the consumer surplus—the amount the consumer benefits from getting a product at less than the price he is willing to pay (pink on the graph)—while the producer surplus—the amount the producer’s benefit from selling a product above the market price—decreases. The problem with increasing the consumer surplus in the NHL is that most the teams really need that money, and the fans are already willing to pay the price of an NHL ticket because hockey is absolutely better live than on TV.

At first, a price freeze sounds nice to fans. It would seem like a nice gesture, one little assurance of consistency in a time when everything else is uncertain. But “price freeze” reduces the producer surplus—the economic benefit a team gets from fans who are willing to pay the highest prices for tickets. In some cases, nice gestures make for bad business, and in this case the hockey fans will pay for that bad business when their favorite team is forced to cut salaries or move to a better market. It might sound like cold capitalism, but if the Rangers and other teams can’t turn a profit, they won’t be around for fans to enjoy.

Even if you’re confused about graphs and price ceilings, just understand that it doesn’t make sense for any business (which all NHL teams are) to voluntarily limit its profits if there are fans who are willing to pay a higher price. In New York, there will always be fans willing to pay the market price for tickets, the price naturally determined by the demand.

One fan who read Brooks’s column commented: “I always feel like I have been taken advantage of every year and in the playoffs especially. I am one of those season subscription holders that is seriously considering bailing out next year.”  That’s too bad, but it’s exactly the way it should work. When some fans become annoyed by ticket gouging and drop their season tickets, there are plenty of others who will step up and buy the tickets in their place. Madison Square Garden is constantly packed, despite having some of the highest ticket prices in the NHL. Even with the looming recession, a price freeze is foolishness. Let the supply and demand determine the price. If people can’t afford to go to games at a high price, than the demand will go down, and the price will eventually follow. The market works—even for hockey.